Sünnet yapılmayan toplumlarda, hangi sağlık problemi çıkıyorda, müslüman ülkelerde bu çıkmıyor ?
Gerçekten bu sağlık açısından faydalı olsaydı, sünneti, aşı gibi zorunlu tutarlardı eminim.
Zorunlu tutulmadığına göre, hiçbir faydası ve farkı yoktur.
Yurdışında, "geri sünnet ameliyatı" diye birşey duydunuz mu ?
Pişman olanların yaptırdıkları, ikinci ameliyat türü.
Şimdi ben işkembeden sallamak yerine bilimsel konuşmayı tercih ederim,
Uluslararası dergilerde yayınlanmış birkaç makale:
The Medical Benefits of Male Circumcision
"Three randomized trials in Africa JAMA : the journal of the American Medical Association
Author Manuscript
HHS Public Access
The Medical Benefits of Male Circumcision
Aaron A. R. Tobian, MD, PhD and Ronald H. Gray, MD, MSc
Additional article information
With 2 new states recently joining 16 others in eliminating Medicaid insurance for male circumcision, possible ballot initiatives to ban male circumcision, and the long-awaited American Academy of Pediatrics male circumcision policy statement, there is a need to evaluate the medical risks and benefits of male circumcision, particularly in light of recent medical evidence.
Three randomized trials in Africa demonstrated that adult male circumcision decreases human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) acquisition in men by 51% to 60%,1 and the long-term follow-up of these study participants has shown that the protective efficacy of male circumcision increases with time from surgery. These findings are consistent with a large number of observational studies in Africa and in the United States that found male circumcision reduces the risk of JAMA : the journal of the American Medical Association
Author Manuscript
HHS Public Access
The Medical Benefits of Male Circumcision
Aaron A. R. Tobian, MD, PhD and Ronald H. Gray, MD, MSc
Additional article information
With 2 new states recently joining 16 others in eliminating Medicaid insurance for male circumcision, possible ballot initiatives to ban male circumcision, and the long-awaited American Academy of Pediatrics male circumcision policy statement, there is a need to evaluate the medical risks and benefits of male circumcision, particularly in light of recent medical evidence.
Three randomized trials in Africa demonstrated that adult male circumcision decreases human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) acquisition in men by 51% to 60%,1 and the long-term follow-up of these study participants has shown that the protective efficacy of male circumcision increases with time from surgery. These findings are consistent with a large number of observational studies in Africa and in the United States that found male circumcision reduces the risk of HIV infection in men.1 Thus, there is substantial evidence that removal of the foreskin reduces the risk of male heterosexual HIV acquisition. However, the effect of male circumcision on reducing HIV acquisition among men who have sex with men is unclear. There may be protection against insertional but not against receptive anal intercourse, so men practicing both forms of sexual intercourse may have limited protection associated JAMA : the journal of the American Medical Association
Author Manuscript
HHS Public Access
The Medical Benefits of Male Circumcision
Aaron A. R. Tobian, MD, PhD and Ronald H. Gray, MD, MSc
Additional article information
With 2 new states recently joining 16 others in eliminating Medicaid insurance for male circumcision, possible ballot initiatives to ban male circumcision, and the long-awaited American Academy of Pediatrics male circumcision policy statement, there is a need to evaluate the medical risks and benefits of male circumcision, particularly in light of recent medical evidence.
Three randomized trials in Africa demonstrated that adult male circumcision decreases human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) acquisition in men by 51% to 60%,1 and the long-term follow-up of these study participants has shown that the protective efficacy of male circumcision increases with time from surgery. These findings are consistent with a large number of observational studies in Africa and in the United States that found male circumcision reduces the risk of HIV infection in men.1 Thus, there is substantial evidence that removal of the foreskin reduces the risk of male heterosexual HIV acquisition. However, the effect of male circumcision on reducing HIV acquisition among men who have sex with men is unclear. There may be protection against insertional but not against receptive anal intercourse, so men practicing both forms of sexual intercourse may have limited protection associated with male circumcision.
In addition to HIV, male circumcision has been shown to reduce the risk of other heterosexually acquired sexually transmitted infections (STIs). Two trials demonstrated that male circumcision reduces the risk of acquiring genital herpes by 28% to 34%, and the risk of developing genital ulceration by 47%.
Additionally, the trials found that male circumcision reduces the risk JAMA : the journal of the American Medical Association
Author Manuscript
HHS Public Access
The Medical Benefits of Male Circumcision
Aaron A. R. Tobian, MD, PhD and Ronald H. Gray, MD, MSc
Additional article information
With 2 new states recently joining 16 others in eliminating Medicaid insurance for male circumcision, possible ballot initiatives to ban male circumcision, and the long-awaited American Academy of Pediatrics male circumcision policy statement, there is a need to evaluate the medical risks and benefits of male circumcision, particularly in light of recent medical evidence.
Three randomized trials in Africa demonstrated that adult male circumcision decreases human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) acquisition in men by 51% to 60%,1 and the long-term follow-up of these study participants has shown that the protective efficacy of male circumcision increases with time from surgery. These findings are consistent with a large number of observational studies in Africa and in the United States that found male circumcision reduces the risk of HIV infection in men.1 Thus, there is substantial evidence that removal of the foreskin reduces the risk of male heterosexual HIV acquisition. However, the effect of male circumcision on reducing HIV acquisition among men who have sex with men is unclear. There may be protection against insertional but not against receptive anal intercourse, so men practicing both forms of sexual intercourse may have limited protection associated with male circumcision.
In addition to HIV, male circumcision has been shown to reduce the risk of other heterosexually acquired sexually transmitted infections (STIs). Two trials demonstrated that male circumcision reduces the risk of acquiring genital herpes by 28% to 34%, and the risk of developing genital ulceration by 47%.1 Additionally, the trials found that male circumcision reduces the risk of oncogenic high-risk human papillomavirus (HR-HPV) by 32% to 35%.1 While some consider male circumcision to be primarily a male issue, one trial also reported derivative benefits for female partners of circumcised men; the risk of HR-HPV for female partners was reduced by 28%, the risk of bacterial vaginosis was reduced by 40%, and the risk of trichomoniasis was reduced by 48%.1,2
The incidence of viral STIs in the United States is disproportionately higher among disadvantaged minority populations such as blacks and Hispanics, who have the lowest rates of male circumcision.
Using mathematical models and cost-effectiveness analyses, the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) and the World Health Organization adopted a policy advocating male circumcision in countries and regions with heterosexual HIV epidemics."
Şimdi benim inanan inanmayan akıl sahibi arkadaşlara saygım var. Burda din tartışması çok da ilgimi çekmiyor ama kendi alanımda biri atıp tutarsa da voleyi yapıştırırım.
Makalede daha çok erişkin hayata değinilmis olsa da erkek çocuklarda tekrarlayan idrar yolu enfeksiyonunu büyük oranda düşürdüğü bir gerçek.
Neonatal sünnet tercih edilmesinin sebebi ise çocuk doğar doğmaz ameliyathane koşullarında profesyonel bir ekiple birşey hissetmeden tatbik edilmesi ve iyileşmenin yenidoğan döneminde çok hızlı olması (göbek düşmesinden daha hızlı) ve çocuğun ileri hayatında bunu hatırlamayacaği için psikolojik travma yasamamasidir.
t★p★t★p★